Sunday, October 4, 2026

Ahmes going to St. Ives

Have you ever wanted to try a math problem that’s over 3000 years old? What about one that Fibonacci may have done? What if these were the same problem? The Ahmes going to St. Ives riddle is an example of “the dressing of word problems” that has stood the test of time. You can see in the screenshots of the riddle below from our Math History for Teachers class blog that these riddles are all about powers of 7, but dressed up with different text. We solved each of these riddles using the techniques available at the time, essentially solving the same riddle 3 different ways.

Ancient Egypt:

It was fun to try the Egyptian doubling technique to solve this puzzle. One of the calculations we did is shown below to get the number of mice, i.e. 49*7:


Multiplier

Double

Egyptian

1

49

||||||||||ՈՈՈՈ

2

98

||||||||ՈՈՈՈՈՈՈՈՈ

4

196

||||||ՈՈՈՈՈՈՈՈՈ𑁯


As we were shown in class, the multiplier column adds to 7, so we keep all rows and just sum them up to get 343.


We noticed that the exercise became even easier (almost trivial) when we used the Egyptian numerals to double because that involved literally doubling the symbols and then counting groups of 10 to see if any symbol needed to be “carried”. One interesting thing we noticed is that our inclination was to write the symbols representing larger powers of 10 on the left just like we would do with the numerics we’re familiar with. Brandon pointed out that the Egyptians actually wrote them the other way around.

Fibonacci’s time:

Fibonacci would have been using roman numerals. These numerals are notoriously difficult to work with, making multiplication with them very tricky. We found that they would have used an “abacus-like” counting board to do their multiplying. Below we show an example of what that would look like to get the number of knives in Fibonacci’s problem, i.e. 343*7:


Start with 343 represented by tokens on the counting board:

M ----------

C --○○○-----

X --○○○○----

I --○○○-----


Each row is multiplied by 7 individually:


M ----------

C --○○○----- x7 -> 21 tokens where "2" moves to the thousands line, 1 is left in the hundred line

X --○○○○---- x7 -> 28 tokens, 2 moves to the hundreds line, 8 tokens stay on the tens line

I --○○○----- x7 -> 21 tokens again, 2 moves up, 1 stays


becomes


M -○○-------

C -○○○------

X ○○○○○○○○○○ there's 10 here! So the 1 moves up and we have 0 in the tens row

I -○--------


so we get (2401)


M -○○-------

C -○○○○-----

X ----------

I -○--------


Which they would have written as MMCDI. (Note that D represents 500, much like V represents 5).

And a more modern version from England:

For this one we could use techniques more familiar to us, namely the Geometric equation. For the sum of a finite series we have:




Which if we plug in the values from our riddle we have:




But we don’t want to include the man himself! So below we will subtract off 7^0.


Using the geometric series and making sure to subtract the man we have:




So this is the solution we got for the other techniques as well: 19607. Except is this actually the solution for the English riddle?


After reading the question again we actually realized we made the mistake of assuming the problem was exactly the same as the others. While in reality this one DOES include the man and we actually only need 4 powers of 7. So we could have used the formula as is with n=5 and gotten: 2801. However this answer is not quite right either because the puzzle begins with “I was going to St. Ives”, so the actual answer is 2802 if you include the original question asker. This is an example where seeing very similar word problems can actually trick you into assuming they’re all the same and glossing over the details of each.

Activity and extensions

Because we had fun playing with the Egyptian numerals and saw the beauty and simplicity in using them to double we wanted to give the class a chance to try this too. This is why we asked the class to try writing the numerals for themselves and seeing how doubling felt to them.


Other cool extension activities involve working with other bases. You can have students use counting boards to introduce working with different bases where the lines would represent powers of the base you’re interested in instead of powers of 10. This offers a visual aid to working with bases which can often feel confusing at first. You could also have students draw their own versions of “Egyptian” numerals representing the digits in the base they’re working with and try to draw out various multiplications. This would allow students to tap into their creative sides and feel connected to the numerals they create. Connecting to the riddles themselves and the way they span history is also just a very interesting way to introduce geometric series to students.


There is the added lesson in all this. By going through this exercise students will learn that having multiple techniques to solve the same problem not only allows you to double check your answers, but it also gives you a deeper understanding of the mathematics involved in the problem.


2 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You and your group has done an excellent job, and have taken the extensions and explorations to so many interesting places! Great work.

    ReplyDelete

November 18th blog post

When I was reading the article, my first stop was when Alice mentioned how the Mayans used head variants to symbolize the first 20 digits. I...